24 November 2017

The sheep and the goats – 24 November 2017


This Sunday is the last of the old liturgical year, and the following Sunday is the First in Advent, a new Christian year.  In 1925, Pope Pius XI decreed that this Sunday would be called Christ the King, and the lectionary takes us to Matthew 25 and the stern account of the Sheep and the Goats.  Christ the King in glory sits in judgement and separates the sheep from the goats, on the basis of how they have given food to the hungry, drink to the thirsty, welcomed strangers, clothed the naked, cared for the sick and visited those in prison – or how they have not done these things.

Rather more ancient is an Anglican designation for this Sunday, which comes from the Collect for the day in the 1534 Book of Common Prayer: Stir up, we beseech thee, O Lord, the wills of thy faithful people; that they, plenteously bringing forth the fruit of good works, may of thee be plenteously rewarded… So it has been popularly known as Stir-Up Sunday -- and a timely signal therefore to make the Christmas pudding. 

But all this is putting off the moment when we respond intelligently to this strange picture of Christ the King, sitting in glory and in final judgement, separating people, labelling them indelibly sheep or goat, saved or lost, on the basis of their service record (…unto me) – and consigning the failed, the goats to perdition.  It is uncomfortably reminiscent of horrifying separations at Auschwitz or Ravensbrück, and such other hideous things that are happening still to people in 2017.  The narrative in Matthew takes no account of who had seriously tried but failed in life, or of people who never had a chance, or people who laboured under crippling handicaps not of their doing or deserving, or people who did everything right but for self-serving motives.  Robert Burns put it better:  What’s done we partly may compute, but know not what’s resisted.[1]

There are numerous Christians who accept this story with its uncompromising message… and are presumably unworried about its implications… or simply hope they’re among the sheep.  But there are others of us who encounter Jesus very differently.  In his kingdom, as he said, we do not have a binary society of winners and losers, us and them, the right and the wrong, black and white, rich and poor, male and female, Christian and Moslem, Protestant and Catholic, Jew and Gentile, whole and broken.  Neither did St Paul, we should note.  Far from separating the sheep from the goats, wrote Paul, Jesus demolishes walls, heals divisions.[2]  In John 17 Jesus prays: …that they may be one, as we are one.

The walls and divisions come down first in our hearts, the primary battleground, and the process continues to happen there in a practice of silence and stillness, dissolving prejudices, calming fears of difference or of being vulnerable, replacing blame and guilt with mercy and love.  And a different person means, to that extent at any rate, a different world.



[1] Robert Burns: Address to the Unco Guid or the Rigidly Righteous.  It’s worth reading… based on Ecclesiastes 7:16.
[2] See Ephesians 2:13-22.

No comments:

Post a Comment