24 May 2019

The Noonday Demon – Easter VI, 24 May 2019


St Benedict was well aware that a practice of contemplative prayer in daily life can be at times a puzzling, even discouraging process.  He therefore stressed the virtue of ‘stability’, stabilitas, by which he meant among other things the quality of perseverance.  Stabilitas is the inner commitment of the best part of us, our rootedness in where we are in the present and in God’s dealings with us.  We are here, not “somewhere over the rainbow”.

What do we do, for instance, when we feel simply reluctant to meditate?  What do we do, when we feel we can’t be bothered?  What do we do, when we feel a failure in meditation, because, it seems, “nothing happens”?  The virtue of stabilitas teaches us a kind of spiritual cussedness -- we sit down as usual and say our word, our mantra.  We remind ourselves that our feelings are not the issue, and are anyway a poor guide, and an even worse master.  We persevere regardless of what happens… or doesn’t.  The beauty is that something is indeed happening, but at a level beyond our surface personality and our anxious judgemental ego.  If we let it be, and trust, meditation allows re-creation, we are further along the road.

Benedict was certainly influenced by the teaching of the Desert Fathers and Mothers of the 4th century.  The boredom, the aridity, the ‘what is the point?’ was well known to them. They called this paralysing emotion Acedia, or the Noonday Demon.
[1]  A quote from the desert:

The demon of acedia - also called the noonday demon - is the one that causes the most serious trouble of all.  He presses his attack upon the monk [the meditator] about the fourth hour [10 a.m.] and besieges the soul until the eighth hour [2.00 p.m.].  First of all he makes it seem that the sun barely moves, if at all, and that the day is fifty hours long.  Then he constrains the monk to look constantly out of the windows, to walk outside the cell, to gaze carefully at the sun to determine how far it stands from the ninth hour [3.00 p.m. the main meal] to look now this way and now to that to see if perhaps one of the brethren appears from his cell.  Then too he instils in the heart of the monk a hatred for the place, a hatred for his very life itself, a hatred for manual labour.  He leads him to reflect that charity has departed from among the brethren, that there is no one to give encouragement.  Should there be someone who happens to offend him in some way or other, this too the demon uses to contribute further to his hatred.  This demon drives him along to desire other sites where he can more easily procure life’s necessities, more readily find work and make a real success of himself… 

These feelings may be eerily familiar: I’m bored; other people are not pulling their weight; I loathe this place; wouldn’t it be better just to read a book about it all?  Perhaps I need a change of church. A walk in nature would be just as good.  Well, the wisdom is to persevere, stabilitas...  The answer, as is so often the case in faith, is simply to take the next step.  More is happening than we can possibly know, right now.



[1] See Kathleen Norris: Acedia & Me (Penguin 2008)

17 May 2019

Simplicity – Easter V, 17 May 2019


Contemplative life and prayer encourages us to prefer simplicity.  Part of simplicity is indeed what is popularly called downsizing – what you have to do to go and live in Summerset Falls – getting rid of stuff, stuff we once needed,  stuff we may never have needed.  It’s making space.  Simplicity however is also doing this task inwardly – seeing the ego downsized, its many demands and expectations, discovering how to live fulfillingly, simply – as some writers put it, learning to find happiness in the right places.  St Paul said: I have learned, in whatsoever state I am, therewith to be content.[1]

We learn about letting go as an alternative to possessing and controlling.  Of course we still need to be comfortable and fed, and in pleasant surroundings, sheltered, reasonably secure – none of that is in question here, although we know even those basic requirements millions today can only dream about.  We are challenged to be discerning – seeing more clearly what matters and what doesn’t, or never did.  There is a principle in classical philosophy called Occam’s Razor.  The medieval Franciscan, William of Ockham, taught that simpler solutions are more likely to be correct than complex ones.  God, say some of the great theologians, is infinite simplicity… which leads to the next point:  Simplicity surely means also simplicity of belief.  Jesus advocated being like little children.  He did not mean naïve, infantile or deliberately ignorant.  I think he did mean that requirements in our beliefs about God, Christ and the Bible, which divide and confuse and condemn, are actually surplus requirements.  William of Ockham was right – simplicity waits in the wings.  The Apostle John writes: God is love, and whoever abides in love abides in God.[2]  That is simplicity.  It is the being of it and the doing of it that is the ground of faith.  Abiding in love.

Downsizing however, as we well know, is probably very difficult.  I have lots of stuff I scarcely need, but do not want to be without right now all the same.  If circumstances were to decree immediate downsizing – if for instance I went to prison – it would be a big task for someone.  Interior downsizing is really not much easier.  I remain confused by complexity and unanswered questions that don’t simply go away.  Life is often noisy and busy, of necessity.  But we are practising Christian Meditation.  It is a plug of simplicity in our lives, like a plug of healthy grass you might put in your lawn in the hope that it will seed and spread… a kind of transplant, a complexity bypass, if that’s not too fanciful. 

I am sure that contemplative life and prayer, which is an exercise in simplicity, and is without boundaries or prior conditions, is a vital pathway onward for Jesus’s followers.  As Thomas Merton put it, faith is not the determination to cling to any form of words, biblical or liturgical or theological, but is the opening of the inward eye, the eye of the heart, to life and to God.  On this path we can indeed address the very personal challenges of simplicity in a complex and increasingly threatening world.



[1] Philippians 4:11.  “Content” is autarkēs (αὐταρκης), a word which in ordinary speech means “enough”. 
[2] I John 4:16

10 May 2019

Cheap and Costly Grace – Easter IV, 10.5.19


As Hitler took over power in Germany, and fascist military regimes were spreading arrogance and cruelty far and wide, Pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer and others recognised a huge and urgent kairos, a wake-up call for the Christian Church.  In 1937 Bonhoeffer wrote about cheap grace (Billige Gnade).  Cheap Grace, he said, is grace without discipleship.  Fr Laurence Freeman describes cheap grace as the kind we bestow on ourselves… in our religious frame of mind.  It's the kind we get when we use the church to satisfy ourselves.  It's grace without really following, without being a disciple.  It's the cheap grace of the Christian who says I prefer to stay as I am.  I'm okay, leave me alone, don't ask me to grow or change. That's not the way of a disciple.  Costly grace, on the other hand, wrote Bonhoeffer, confronts us as a gracious call to follow Jesus, it comes as a word of forgiveness to the broken spirit and the contrite heart.  It is costly because it compels us to submit to the yoke of Christ and follow him; it is grace because Jesus says: "My yoke is easy and my burden is light."

Let’s look again at what we mean by grace.  In the Greek scriptures, charis… in Hebrew, chesed… two profoundly important words in understanding our faith.  Grace is the goodness we receive which we didn’t expect and neither earned nor deserved.  Grace is “love… nevertheless”.  Love despite, perhaps.  But grace comes with a corollary – if you are the recipient of grace, your life turns towards it, you change.   Of his fullness have we all received, writes John, grace upon grace. He goes on:  The Law was given through Moses… That is the law which defines what you deserve or do not deserve.  …grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.[1]  That is the “law” which says that love prevails because God is love and no one is lost.

Costly grace, then, is God’s grace received and known in humble gratitude and wonder.  This grace displaces the ego, the self, because we are less and less captivated by the self, charmed by it, or protective of ourselves.  The church at its best is a channel of the costly grace which changes us into disciples – it means learners, listeners.  Bonhoeffer’s concern was that the church of his day, by and large, was existing for its own sake, compromising with fascism and its horrors, occupied mainly with survival, and therefore purveying cheap grace.

We are in another kairos – and one of the signs of this is our loss of confidence.  What were familiar landmarks in faith seem to disappear.  The church seems scarcely to know what to say.  But then, more and more people no longer wonder or care what the church has to say.  Secularism prevails, some of it sensible, much of it pernicious.  This is a kairos which calls us to be still, steady, and be formed and re-formed by God in Christ.  Believers are now able to rediscover inwardness and its strength, along with discerning again what to let go of – which is quite a lot -- and what to embrace.  This teaching, grown-up faith, I would say, is always going to surprise us.  We are being ministered to in a time of need by costly grace and wisdom.



[1] John 1:16-17

03 May 2019

After daybreak – Easter III, 3 May 2019


Just after daybreak, Jesus stood on the beach; but the disciples did not know that it was Jesus. (John 21:4)

I don’t know how that could be, that they didn’t recognise him, but we hear it repeatedly in the gospel accounts of Jesus’s resurrection.  He appears, unexpectedly, and they don’t know who he is.  The gospel writers, dealing now more than ever with mystery and wonder, are very soon making copious use of symbolism – here for instance, it’s just after daybreak, symbolising the dawning of their new life, Easter life.  Jesus is on the beach -- in all literature the beach is potent as a symbol of life on the border, transition between past and future, known and unknown, safety and peril.  Jesus, we find, is also very human here… he is wounded, and in Luke’s Gospel he actually asks, Is there anything to eat? 

So it’s strange.  And strangest of all is that, whether it was Mary at the tomb, or the disciples on the lake, or on the road to Emmaus, they didn’t know at first who he was.  Albert Schweitzer understood this, I think.  Schweitzer was a French/German (Alsace) medical missionary in Africa, in what is now Gabon.  A devout Lutheran Christian of independent mind, Schweitzer was theologian, organist (he was an authority on J S Bach), writer, philosopher, physician, Nobel Peace Prize winner of 1952.[1]  This is what he wrote about Jesus:  He comes to us as one unknown, without a name, as of old, by the lakeside, he came to those who did not know him.  He speaks to us the same words: "Follow me!" and sets us to the tasks which he has to fulfil for our time.  He commands.  And to those who obey him, whether they be wise or simple, he will reveal himself in the toils, the conflicts, the sufferings which they shall pass through in his fellowship, and, as an ineffable mystery, they shall learn in their own experience who he is.

I find this totally encouraging.  The risen Lord is encountered in life’s depths and predicaments, trials, doubts and disasters.  It is a matter of being still and waiting.  We find him in our confusion and setbacks.  We learn discernment, preferring silence and stillness.  Eventually we know, or suspect, who he is.

It is far removed from the embarrassment intelligent and sensitive Christian faith has suffered lately, with Destiny Church zealots gathered in Hagley Park, directly over the road from the Al Noor mosque, to broadcast their testimonies and, as they put it, “reclaim Christchurch for Jesus”.  This dogmatism and arrogance has little to do with the way of Jesus.  Neither the gospel of Christ nor the city of Christchurch depend on any of this for faith and truth.  The risen Lord, hidden and mysterious, and totally humble, has been ministering in the hearts of Christian, Jew, Moslem, long before we came along.  The point is not to bring him back – he never left -- the point is to meet him where he is, and always was, with his humility and simplicity and love.



[1] While completing his doctorate in theology, Schweitzer somehow studied medicine in Strasbourg, and was an organ pupil of Charles-Marie Widor.  Later he recorded much of Bach’s organ opus.

26 April 2019

All things new – Easter II, 26 April 2019


When native wit, after all these years, is simply weary (or wary) of trying to express the truths of resurrection adequately in words, it’s not a bad idea to turn to poetry.  I went back to this Hebrew prophet of the Exile.[1]  He is one of three different prophets in what we now call the Book of Isaiah, and he lived about 500 years before Jesus.  The Jews had come back from Babylon after some two generations in exile.  It was their grandparents who had last seen Jerusalem, as children.  On their return to what war had destroyed long ago, they had to cope not only with rebuilding but also with other people now living there.  How familiar is this?  Here is the prophet’s poetry.  He tells how God sees it:

For I am about to create new heavens and a new earth; the former things shall not be remembered or come to mind.  But be glad and rejoice forever in what I am creating; for I am about to create Jerusalem as a joy, and its people as a delight. I will rejoice in Jerusalem, and delight in my people; no more shall the sound of weeping be heard in it, or the cry of distress.  No more shall there be in it an infant who lives but a few days, or an old person who does not live out a lifetime…  They shall build houses and inhabit them; they shall plant vineyards and eat their fruit.  They shall not build and another inhabit; they shall not plant and another eat; for like the days of a tree shall the days of my people be, and my chosen shall long enjoy the work of their hands.  They shall not labour in vain, or bear children for calamity…   Before they call I will answer, while they are yet speaking I will hear.  The wolf and the lamb shall feed together, the lion shall eat straw like the ox; but the serpent—its food shall be dust!  They shall not hurt or destroy on all my holy mountain, says the Lord.

It is a sublime, impossible vision of resurrection – all things new -- and all these many years later, I find, it is easier to describe resurrection not so much in the words of theology and belief, as by quietly noting where we see it, or saw it, marking the changes we didn’t expect.  I have attended Easter services where the announcement of Jesus’s resurrection was accompanied by much shouting and by a fanfare on the organ trumpets.  It is worth remembering that the risen Lord, on the first Easter morning, mests Mary of Magdala in her grief, quietly.  At first she thinks he is the gardener.  He joins the disciples walking to Emmaus as an interesting companion on the road.  They know him later in the breaking of bread. 

Tomorrow shall be my dancing day, sings a very old English carol.  It pictures Jesus singing, I would my true love did so chance / to see the legend of my play / to call my true love to my dance.   We are called to his dance, in a frightening, suffering world.  Our friend Michael Dougherty, who leads meditation groups in Whangarei, very timely sent an Easter poem in which he wrote of Mother Julian of Norwich:  And Mother Julian cried out: What was the Lord's meaning? She was answered: Love was his meaning ….. remain in this, and you will know more of the same.



[1] The Old Testament reading for Easter Day – Isaiah 65:17-25

12 April 2019

Silence and speech – 12 April 2019


…he will, when I speak, be nameless. And to others I implore you: speak the names of those who were lost, rather than the name of the man who took them. He may have sought notoriety, but we in New Zealand will give him nothing. Not even his name. (Jacinda Ardern in the NZ Parliament, 19.3.19)

This caught the attention of, among many, Dr Cynthia Lindner of the University of Chicago Divinity School.  She wrote in wonder of “a media-saturated moment” in which the NZ Prime Minister counsels silence. 

Silence…?  Dr Cynthia points out: …it is a cause for pause when we are asked, implored, not to speak something.  Choosing not to say -- that is, choosing silence -- runs counter to our impulse… That impulse is understandable, and not insignificant, as some of our voices have been hard won.

Of course, the events of 15 March in Christchurch were followed by torrents of words.  We had media reporters, themselves deeply moved, trying everything to make sure we had the facts, even about how people allegedly felt.  We had the police issuing warnings, and officials giving instructions.  We had the stumbling testimonies of witnesses and wounded… and their friends and family.  Then came the wordy reactions of leaders, philosophers, teachers… and of other prime ministers and presidents. 

Through it all, our Jacinda counselled silence about the gunman’s identity.  A week later, having to say something at a vast community event in Christchurch, she said perhaps three sentences – and then sat down.  During the week she had made only the necessary statements, about security and about gun law.

In many ways it is indeed better to be still.  A lot of people don’t know that.  Silence is one of the “thin” or liminal spaces, writes Dr Cynthia.  Silence is a “place” where the light may shine through, where we may hear a word that illuminates, changes things.  So it is important to know how to shut down the chatter and be still, and to wait.  God’s first language is silence, said St John of the Cross – the Moslem Sufi poet Jalal al Din Rumi, said it some three centuries earlier.  Here are words from an American poet laureate, Billy Collins:

And there is the silence of this morning
which I have broken with my pen, a silence that had piled up all night
like snow falling in the darkness of the house—
the silence before I wrote a word
and the poorer silence now. 
  (“Silence” by Billy Collins, 2005)

Dr Cynthia points out that “free speech” has unfortunately come to mean, not restraint or discipline, but hapless, heedless, and regardless of harm.  It is certainly so in the social media.  It is time to brush up on silence.  Most of the time we do not have to proclaim who we are and what we stand for.  We do not have to plant stakes in the ground about what we are for or against, or what we think.  It is time to be what we are, consistently, to enjoy the openness Jesus makes around us.  Dr Cynthia, who for all her advocacy of silence is still pretty good with words, reminds us… of the subversive power of silence that can help us reclaim the story…and relearn the world. 

05 April 2019

No one vexed – 5 April 2019


In the Rule of St Benedict there is a section describing the monastery Cellarer.  The Cellarer is what in the military would be called the Quartermaster, in charge of supply and provision of food and drink and necessary equipment.  Benedict says the Cellarer must be humble and kind, should stick to his job without trying to turn it into a powerful fief, should be efficient, and sensitive to individual need.  And all this, says Benedict, is so that no one may be troubled or vexed in the house of God.  We know what “troubled” means… I think “vexed”, not a word we often use[1], means feeling at least irritated as well as troubled.  The Latin contristetur includes being made sad and possibly angry.

The idea of no one being troubled or vexed in the house of God may sound to us like Shangri-La.  Things do go wrong.  Human pride and perversity, even silly misunderstandings, guarantee that.  If you read the histories of great parishes in New Zealand, and of great church leaders, they are peppered with scandal, dispute, failure, schism and bitterness, at times. 

In contemplative life and prayer we have another frame of reference.  One of the commentators on this passage in the Rule of St Benedict says we are told not to react to those buttons pushed, (except) with love and humility.  We start to learn how to step back, how not to follow anyone else’s agenda of labelling, categorising, passing simplistic judgement, letting emotions rule and decide. 

We become acquainted with compassion, and with what it really means.  Compassion is a Latin derivation which means to suffer with, to share the pain, or sorrow, or bewilderment, or confusion, as it may be.  The equivalent Greek word arrives in English as sympathy, to suffer together with.  So sentimentalism, the popular secular refuge, is not the same as compassion… nor is having once had that happen to me…  In the company of Jesus the first task is not to feel sorry – how we feel is not the point – but to seek to understand and to be present to bear the weight, even the weight of guilt.  Understanding does entail being able to be still, to listen and to pay attention, the willingness to set ego aside, and not be driven by fear.

In Jesus’s company, what Benedict calls the house of God, it is not that everything is serene… that is indeed unlikely… but that our instinct is to bear one another’s burdens, including burdens of guilt and failure – and to decline other agendas.  Paul writes to the Colossians:  Clothe yourselves with compassion, kindness, humility, meekness and patience.  Bear with one another, and if anyone has a complaint, forgive each other…  Above all clothe yourselves with love…  And let the peace[2] of Christ rule in your hearts… and be thankful.[3] 




[1] In Pride and Prejudice, Mrs Bennet cries, “Oh Mr Bennet! nothing you say will ever vex me again!”  Mr Bennet replies, “I am sorry to hear that, my dear.”
[2] In Hebrew: Shalom…  In Arabic: Salaam…
[3] Colossians 3:12-15