06 March 2015

Jesus with a whip – Lent III, 6 March 2015


In the temple he found people selling cattle, sheep, and doves, and the money changers seated at their tables. Making a whip of cords, he drove all of them out…  [John 2:14-15]

A besetting sin of the church and of most of us in it at some time is what we can call the domestication of God, which is simply the making of idols.  And so in its extremes God may come to bear an uncanny resemblance to a British Tory, or a United States Republican, or to dear old Uncle Algernon, kind and gentle and mercifully remote.  Jesus turns out as portrayed in those Victorian coloured posters which once papered the walls of Sunday schools, walking through flowery fields in the sunshine, blessing children and little lambs, sitting on a rock teaching with uplifting words.  Even pictures of the crucifixion, which could only have been a hideous, filthy and bloody event, seem somehow sanitised.   And so we end up with a sort of benign idolatry, worshipping a God we create, to whom we make requests.  Of course that is in some respects a caricature... but it is not for nothing that Jewish faith insisted that you cannot see or image God, and the Second Commandment forbade idolatry utterly.  Jesus, writes St Paul, is the icon of God.  But I do not recall Jesus portrayed on the Sunday school wall, flailing a whip, tipping up the tables of the money-changers and scattering it all across the ground, chasing the animals out of the sacred precincts and opening the cages of doves.

You would have to be very angry to do that.  I hate to think what the Jerusalem Chamber of Commerce had to say about it – they would have been angry too.  The actual traders, dealers in currency, sellers of sacrificial animals, would scarcely have been amused.  The temple officials, the junior priests charged to see that it all happened as it should and that the temple got its share of the proceeds, would have had to face their superiors who would have been incandescent.  Whose anger was right?

Jesus did it moreover with a whip in his hand.  I remember back in student days long ago, one of my colleagues who later became distinguished saying, “Perhaps it was just a very little whip…”  He was already instinctively domesticating and sanitising and constructing idols. 

Jesus was in high indignation.  My Father’s house…  He had just come to Jerusalem.  This was the scene he saw in the temple.  Ordinary folk were being shut out by religious rules and by queues and protocols that favoured privilege, shut out by clamour, by commercial exploitation and rip-off, by a religious system more geared to its own survival than to caring for widows and orphans…  It was the incessant din of idolatry, shutting out true devotion and truth.

The silence and stillness we practise are the obverse of all that.  We are laying our idols aside, so far as we can.  And so far as we can’t, we are helped by the Spirit of Jesus.  Anger too…  I sometimes think that anger might be the last to go.  I want to retain anger, so long as I see people beheaded by religious fanatics, maimed and starved in the desert by warfare, kidnapped, raped and blown up…  Jesus had times when searing anger was appropriate, with a whip.   I carry that too into the silence.  It turns out to be something that doesn’t necessarily need healing at this time.

No comments:

Post a Comment